I spent the last three weeks reading this textbook, as suggested by one of the members of my committee and have become intimately familiar with it's content. So, it only makes sense for me to do a quick synopsis of this book, to share my opinions on it. (Not that my opinion makes a big difference to the author, I'm sure, but hey, if you're reading my blog, you'll be used to hearing my opinions.)
The first thing I have to say is that this textbook is very well written. It's clear, it's concise, and it explains complex processes very well. On that point alone, I can't see anyone in this field who would find any reason not to keep a copy nearby. This book is now one of two that actually sits out on my book case, within arms reach. (The other is Voet
, Biochemistry - My other textbooks sit in a filing cabinet a few feet away.)
One of the things that impressed me most about this textbook was the CD-Rom in the back. I can't tell you how many times I've been disappointed by the contents of the CDs
that accompany textbooks, but this one surprised me. I watched the small number of movies, which didn't do much for me, but moved on into the "sidebars" and artwork, and that's where I found the true value. The supplementary sidebars are really neat, and add a lot of context to the material in the text. They're optional, but are a really great way of reinforcing some of the information that appears in the text. The artwork is also incredibly valuable. I know I've often looked at figures in textbooks and wished it were available to include in a presentation I'm working on - eg
. my comprehensive exam talk - and not been able to find something comparable elsewhere that fits. Here, every single figure in the text is given to you as a .jpg
or comparable file. That alone might make this textbook worth buying! (Note, the images are copyright, so you can't distribute them, but you can certainly incorporate them or modify them under the fair use
section of copyright law - or whatever your local laws provide.)
I mentioned the supplementary sidebars on the CD, but the text itself is full of them, and they are a very effective way of keeping you interested in the material. They're full of interesting facts, examples of how information was discovered, what exceptions exist to the rules... and the occasional discussion of how the information impacts cancer patients. They truly make the textbook a joy to read.
Of course, with all the positive
comments above, you might think this is the perfect textbook - and it's pretty close, I'll have to admit, but there were a few things that I wasn't too thrilled about.
My biggest complaint is that much of the textbook is organized around either chronological events, or a sort of detective style story, leading you through the "how" and the "why" of each discovery. In many chapters, this is an extremely effective device, but there were times when I just wanted to find out how things work and not have to follow all of the twists and turns that faced the scientists who did the work.
With that said, the next complaint was that when the twists and turns were interesting and I wanted to follow up more on the work, I found it difficult or impossible to figure out which of the references cited for each chapter were relevant. There is no guide to which articles or publications were used at any point. It makes the paragraphs easier on the eyes, I suppose, but can be very discouraging if you just want to track down a particular experiment or two.
Finally, my third complaint is the synopsis and prospects section at the end of each chapter. For the most part, I really enjoyed these sections, but their purpose was relatively vague. Sometimes they performed a review, while in other chapters they introduced entirely new concepts. Again, this is a minor complaint, but it did irk me when I thought I was reviewing the chapter and would come across things I did not recall seeing earlier. (Much page flipping would ensue.)
Making up for the synopsis and prospects section, however, is a great "key concepts" section that invariably follows. This was a key tool for my review - if anything in the key concepts section that seemed unfamiliar or unclear would send me back into the chapter to make sure I hadn't missed things. It really reinforced the lessons found earlier in the chapter, in case
I'd been dozing somewhere earlier in the 60-80 pages per chapter.
So, to sum up my review, this textbook got a 9 out of 10. It was infinitely more readable than most science textbooks, told a great story, and provides an extremely valuable reference for people in the field. However, that last 10% was somewhat disappointing
in making it a great starting point for further research, simply because the author didn't provide an easy way to access the primary material while reading, and the matter of having to wade through a lot of history to get to the current status of the research on each topic.